Direct vs Advised Personal Insurance: Pros and Cons

Kim Bryant - Thrive Plan Logo

We’ve all seen them: the TV ads promising to connect you with a personal insurance policy in just a few moments, without having to submit to rigorous medical testing or questionnaires. You may have even been tempted to sign up there and then – after all, some insurance is better than no insurance and you’ve just been too busy to give it much more thought.

But these insurance policies, which are known collectively as direct insurance, usually have a few undisclosed downsides that can leave you in trouble if you ever need to make a claim.

As your resident team of insurance professionals, we wanted to break down exactly what the pros and cons of direct insurance are – as well as those of its alternative, advised personal insurance – in order to provide you with the information you need to make a smart insurance decision.

Direct Insurance

Direct insurance is classified as an income protection, total and permanent disability (TPD), trauma or life insurance product that is purchased directly from an insurance provider through an insurance call centre. These policies are usually generalist in nature and often come with a few nasty surprises when it comes time to make a claim.


One of the biggest benefits of direct insurance is the ease and convenience with which you can take out a policy. All it takes is a call to an insurance call centre, during which it’s unlikely you’ll be asked any in-depth questions about your medical history or any pre-existing conditions you may have.

Advertisements for direct insurance often promise that you’ll be able to gain coverage instantly and without any invasive medical tests or gruelling questionnaires. However, just like every other aspect of your financial and personal world is unique, it’s rare that you’ll be able to perfectly fit into the one-size-fits-all model of insurance that direct insurance providers offer. And that’s exactly where direct insurance shows how it can be more trouble than it’s worth.


The reality is that being asked questions about your current health, genetic medical history or any pre-existing conditions – which are known across the industry as underwriting – are essential to ensuring you sign up for an insurance policy that will actually provide you with the support you’ll need if you ever have to make a claim. The reason that direct insurance policies are so quick and easy to sign-up for is because they rarely include underwriting.

In fact, a lack of underwriting can be used by a direct insurance provider to avoid paying out on a claim for the reason that you did not officially disclose any underlying health issues, previous surgeries or pre-existing conditions.

Considering that direct insurance can actually end up being more expensive when compared with a retail policy – (which is fully underwritten and a binding contract) – and without the security of being able to successfully make a claim, direct insurance quickly loses any perks it may have offered.

Advised Insurance

Advised insurance is an income protection, TPD, trauma or life insurance policy obtained through a specialised insurance adviser. Since advised insurance comes with the benefit of having an experienced financial adviser to help you through it, these insurance policies are tailored to your particular financial circumstances and needs.


Advised insurance has a number of benefits. The first, and arguably the most important, is the peace-of-mind that having a financial adviser by your side can give you. During the process of selecting your advised insurance policy, your financial adviser will sit down with you and explain exactly what your contract does and does not cover you for before you agree to proceed. They can also help you to narrow down your options and make recommendations for which policy may work best for your specific needs and circumstances.

The second benefit of advised insurance is gaining access to an experienced insurance professional who can help you understand and provide advice on the complexities of risk insurance. This can include walking you through the differences between a level and stepped premium, the value of a reinstatement benefit or whether or not you can pay for insurance through your superannuation to minimise the pressure on your cash flow.

Finally, choosing advised insurance means choosing to have an insurance professional in your corner to help you through every step of the process if you ever need to make a claim. That’s right, your financial adviser can help you by liaising with insurer’s claim assessment team to ensure you get best possible outcome. And when life throws an unexpected challenge your way, this support can be invaluable in providing you with peace-of-mind and time to focus on getting better.


One of the biggest downsides to choosing advised insurance is that the process of choosing a policy and signing a contract can sometimes be a lengthy one. As part of the pre-underwriting process for advised insurance – which helps make applying for insurance easier in the future – your insurance adviser will require a full disclosure of your health and medical history. They’ll then conduct a thorough analysis of your particular financial situation and prepare a strategy paper, known as a Statement of Advice, that will detail the recommendations and options available to you. This process will usually take a few meetings to ensure that the recommendations being made to you will help you to achieve your exact financial goals.

However, while implementing an advised insurance policy can be time-consuming, it also makes sure that you’ll never have to worry about whether you have the right cover to protect you and your loved ones, no matter what comes your way.

For us, that added peace-of-mind is worth it every time.

Get in touch with a financial advise now!

Privacy Policy | Privacy Collection Statement | Complaints | Financial Services Guide (FSG) Part 1 | FSG Part 2 Advisors

Thrive Plan Pty Ltd ABN 69 611 096 470 is a Corporate Authorised Representative 1256624 | GPS Wealth Ltd | Australian Financial Services Licence 254544 | ABN 17 005 482 726  | | Tel: (02) 8074 8599

General Advice Warning The information provided on this website has been provided as general advice only. We have not considered your financial circumstances, needs or objectives and you should seek the assistance of your GPS Wealth Ltd (GPS) Adviser before you make any decision regarding any products mentioned in this communication. Whilst all care has been taken in the preparation of this material, no warranty is given in respect of the information provided and accordingly neither GPS nor its related entities, employees or agents shall be liable on any ground whatsoever with respect to decisions or actions taken as a result of you acting upon such information.

Start to Thrive.

You may be surprised by how quick we get back to you.
We pride ourselves on our response rates. Try us.

Continue Reading